lidarr/Lidarr

Discogs as a Datasource

YipYup asked for this feature over 2 years ago — 14 comments

YipYup commented over 2 years ago

Discogs is an excellent database that complements MusicBrainz. It would be awesome to have Lidarr support metadata information from the Discogs database. https://www.discogs.com/developers/

| scaronni commented about 2 years ago

Also, discogs has more correct information on less common records.

| greenxeyezz commented about 2 years ago

Couldn't agree more, I understand its low on the totem pole, but music brainz, just sucks. literally. #1 reason why I cannot rely on lidarr.

So many albums mis-represented, mis-titled, mis-everything on musicbrainz that cannot be fixed or changed. With discogs, simple enough to fix anything wrong, and plenty of information that is already correct.

| veksha commented about 2 years ago

this feature request should be in TOP!

| iruoy commented almost 2 years ago

I think this i actually quite important. If you look at the two sources for the same artist you'll see that MusicBrainz only lists 3 albums, 3 singles and a compiliation, while Discogs lists 4 albums, 4 EPs, a DJ Mix and 39 other singles/releases.

https://musicbrainz.org/artist/5347c7dc-a8bd-4a05-8ae1-a17fb1e6a388 https://www.discogs.com/artist/1583805-Phuture-Noize

| LesKent commented over 1 year ago

Absolutely needed. For an very old artist like Jabbo Smiith:

MusicBrainz has only 1 complete release and 1 other release with missing data: https://musicbrainz.org/artist/f785b7c7-83b3-46be-8eb6-31f7a6a6a89d

With Discogs 21 releases with no apparent missing data. https://www.discogs.com/artist/307180-Jabbo-Smith

Many others examples like this available.

| YodaSpow commented over 1 year ago

Totally need this as release for: Red Sonja (Original Soundtrack) (1985) on discogs: https://www.discogs.com/Ennio-Morricone-Red-Sonja-Original-Soundtrack/release/2158275 is not available on musicbrainz which would on manual import in queue would glitch rename the 2 only flac files. (https://musicbrainz.org/release/3e0acca9-a46f-4b5f-88d0-69cc492267e5)

| bwfan49 commented over 1 year ago

I agree we should have Discogs as a de facto source. I currently scan all my albums with MP3 tag and Discogs. Works A+.

| FactoryBlack commented over 1 year ago

I've been checking the progress of this particular feature almost daily since installing lidarr. Would love to receive an update on just how feasible this is. Many auto-taggers seem to navigate their way around discogs' API without any difficulties.

| salazr commented about 1 year ago

Not much else to add. Top feature needed.

ColinSandercock commented about 1 year ago

Any progress on this - the Discogs database has so much more in it - and not just minor artists - examples of artists missing data in Musicbrainz includes AC/DC, Johnny Winter, Led Zep, ... About half the albums or releases I have for them are missing in MB

| DjRicko commented 4 months ago

This is a must have, even with the scripts to import discogs into musicbrainz, it takes way too long for that information to actually propagate into the mirror run by lidarr... It's still missing albums added back in the end of 2019.

| jdomingi commented 4 months ago

Yeah musicbrainz sucks hardcore

| smd100 commented 2 months ago

Discogs datasource is by far #1 requested feature at the moment - any plans to get this up and running? (Used Discogs auto-tagging in MediaMonkey for ages and it's awesome - much much more comprehensive database than Musicbrainz.)

Join the discussion!

Sign-in with GitHub to comment